Custom Search 1

Why 'white' stars like Beyoncé are betraying black women

INFLUENCE: Beyoncé and Nicki Minaj

WATCHING BEYONCE’S triumphant return to the UK stage at this year’s Glastonbury Festival and noticing just how she had changed from her Destiny’s Child era, I couldn’t help but ask myself the question, ‘is the world of the black celebrity and white celebrity colliding?’

Everything about the way she looks has changed. The hair is blonder, the skin lighter and the nose more Aquiline than ever.

Now this is not limited to the Ms. B alone. Just a quick flick through the tabloids and lifestyle magazines which now carry pictures and stories of American black celebrities like Rihanna, Nicki Manaj, Kelly Rowland, Jennifer Hudson etc will show you they are all beginning to morph into the same plastic fantastic as their white counterparts.

The now almost daily bombardment of their interchangeable looks and styles makes you wonder whether more and more are opting to swap their natural God-made looks for the man-made.

In these days where nothing remains hidden, denial of surgical enhancement is as futile as photographic evidence of broader noses, less than perky breasts, darker skins and Kunta Kinte hairlines remain.

I guess we all know that these days in an industry where these women reign supreme, a less than perfect “look” would not be welcomed.

The problem is that for the average Shayquan and Sheniqua, the most successful celebrities symbolize both perfection and fantasy. For the young and fabulous crowd, and for those who really should know better, the world of 21st century celebrity is viewed as though it is a tangible reality.

On a sensible day we know that what we are looking at is a product of armies of stylists, make up artists, air brushers and clever lighting technicians.

But on a not such a good day we forget and head down to the shops along Billericay High Street hunting out Beyonce type bargains. The thing we have forgotten is that somewhere along the way these mega rich celebrities have placed their natural beauty onto a sacrificial altar. And since most of them have similar features they somehow have redefined beauty.

How life has changed! Back in the day, the most we could mimic was the harmless Afro – the bigger the better.

Today it is a lot more sinister as people get into debt, prison, and in the worst case scenario die, chasing the impossible dream of bigger boobs and bigger butts. How impossibly ridiculous is that? Especially when you hear these same women say things like ‘women run the world’, ‘be true to yourself’ and ‘you are beautiful no matter what you look like.’ Yeah, right!

Your Voice

Comments

When an individual has

Taylor's picture
Taylor

When an individual has extreme talent,record company will cheap cirque du soleil tickets do anything to sell them to the most sum of people.

Wed, 2012-03-28 08:43

Women are women ..end

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

Women are women ..end off..have been for eons....i personally dont give a four xxx..and think it is a waste of time and energy..it is a trend ....if yer know what the hell yer are..why worry??.....i am more concerned at the self hatred of young Black men and women who are murdered...by members of the same community...i am appalled..by those in the community who shield those yobs..then complain that nothing is being done by the Police....to solve these crimes...A Black Man is the President of the Free World...which means ...we as a race ..can be whgo the hell we choose..no sky is the limit...we have earned the right...or is this still not enough????....

Wed, 2011-10-19 17:49

Beyonce

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

Bloody hell is she black?? I thought she was latina.

Mon, 2011-10-03 12:39

WIGS & WEAVES!

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

I wish I could wear my natural afro, but i can't due to alopecia and I look like am dying with a bald head!!
So yes, I wear a wig and am very open to everyone that I wear a wig.
People need to find out why some black women wear wigs before they comment!

Thu, 2011-09-15 18:04

SAD

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

This lightenening thing has really gotten out of hand now, its same this african lady who lightened her skin and burnt it up has used herself as an example to people how to love and be comfortable in the the skin that you're in you can google her she is Tinu Oginni.

They've also been bleaching for decades in barbados!! on the 2 of june the barbados press had was to issue a health and hazard warning about the dangers of bleaching cream and a popular cream marked on the jar SUPER BLEACHING CREAM!

Some bajans even go as far as bleaching their anal.

In Trinidad & Tobago they're not warning anyone they're just advertising skin bleaching clinics.

Its happening all over asia and the caribbean.

SIC!

Fri, 2011-09-09 01:28

Why 'white' stars like Beyonce are betraying black women

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

There are much we don't like about ourselves as black women and we will go to extremes to change it. Our skin tone, our nose but mostly our hair. To be honest, I am happy with my medium dark skin colour and nose, but my hair, oh Lordy, it needs some work to make it look as naturally appealing as possible. I chemically relax my hair to make it more managable. I have used hot comb in my younger years to accomplish the same result. If that makes me less a black woman, then I'm guilty. I don't fancy wearing cornrows, dreads, plaits or a 'fro, at least at this moment in time. If afro was back in style I would totally rock it.

In the 70's, afro was a hot style, the bigger the better. But that hair style has come and gone for now. I just told a friend last week, black women have so much diversity with our hair type. We can process it and wear it flat, curly, waving, crinkled, in a 'fro, in a bun( on side, top or back), braided, dreaded and more, yet we feel the need to wear a massive amount of somebody else's hair.

I support black women who want to improve on their looks, but sometimes you go too far and almost lose your identity as a black woman. You all wear too much weave, wigs and braids. You really don't need it to be beautiful. Don't define yourself by your weave, define yourself by the true beauty you possess within and how else your adorn yourself using head scarves, earrings, bangles etc. Your fake hair should be a small extention of who you are. I like to admire my black sisters, but when I see all that weave and wig, it subtracts from the beauty of you. Some of you wear some weave to achieve a certain short style, which is usually in good taste.

Go easy on the false hair and heavy on the smiles and charm.

Sun, 2011-09-04 04:16

Black women and men have

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

Black women and men have being changing their hairstyles and looks just like any other cultural peoples of the world...Beyonce is Afro American...where material wealth and metocratic in complexity...your looks could be the difference between getting the job and not especially in the media music industry. There is a good and bad side, the showing of Black sexuality just draws the guys in to realizing (after being bombarded with imagry of non-Black females as beautiful, and Black females not) that Black famales have got just as much va va voom..I don't think images of Whoopi Goldberg has the same effect...lol

Wed, 2011-08-17 12:37

UyXjJcpnCD

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

This site is like a classroom, execpt I don't hate it. lol

Tue, 2011-08-16 06:11

My looooord!! This paper is

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

My looooord!! This paper is pure jokes!!

Sun, 2011-08-14 03:36

This article is racist

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

This article is racist nonsense!!! many young people have unrealistic expectations of looking like the celebritys they admire (not just shayquan and sheniqua)regardless of colour.The media constantly bombard us with artificial,computer generated,idealised images of supposedly human perfection and then to complain she doesnt look "natural"!!! what rank hypocrisy!!!
What is the medias obsession with her skin tone?? my daughter is mixed race with a similar complexion and she too has had this kind of crap all her life!! small minded people trying to force her to identify with one group or another because of her skin colour!!
im quite shocked at the obvious agenda espoused here,hardly the voice of reason,this is biased,provocative rubbish!!

Sat, 2011-08-13 06:15

Jesus christ, are we really

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

Jesus christ, are we really all THAT shallow? Beyonce was still classed as a black woman the last time I looked. I don't think white people are really bothered about claiming her, so lets all stop worrying. Pathetic article.

Tue, 2011-08-09 01:50

Totally agree with you.

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

Totally agree with you.

Thu, 2011-09-15 12:27

hair today UnbWEAVABLE

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

~It is horrid that black woman are still scared of their natural african hair ~ white girls now are crimping their hair for the kink and we are putting our self forward for self inflicted alopecia ~ ... when black woman see me they hate my Raw Natural Beauty white ladies grab their husbands .. its not fair ~ if these woman really new how powerful and rich we would be if we all as woman loved ourselves 1000% like i do ~ our communities would be ABUNDANT mentally and financially ~ to hell with the unbWeavable image of us Black woman ~ when CJ walker invented the hot comb that is what she did just invented something to make our hair more stylishly feasible for the systematic time schedule of the western world not ~ to walk around with self inflicted alopecia ~ i get so embarrassed when i see weave headed woman its like shall i laugh at you because after all {YOU ALL BLOODY HATE YOURSELF AND SUFFER FROM BODY DISCRIMINATION} and i will rather let my son marry a blond real eurpoean than a mentally sick african with blonde hair ~ cherylin gordon

Tue, 2011-07-19 20:37

Me rah! I cahn believe that I

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

Me rah! I cahn believe that I just read that, and by a black WOMAN too! ****side!! That's what I've been saying for years and it's been so like talking to a brick wall that I've given up! Black women must be the most ridiculous species on the Earth plus, now they've gone in for bleaching dere faces n making themselves look even more like idiots! LOL! That's all I can do, laugh at dem when they're not making me sick! Well done sis, keep up the good work of being proud of your natural body. I'm sure you look gorgeous in your natural afro hair. That's the sort of black chick I'm seeking. None of these false, white-aspiring idiots!!

Sun, 2011-07-24 12:55

Why 'White' Stars Like Beyoncé Are Betraying Black Women

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

How many of you people who found the time to comment about this story found the time to write a comment about how Negus Mclean a 15 year old back boy was hunted down by 7 black youths and killed in front of his brother?

How many of you who commented on this story wrote a comment about ,Agnes Sina-Inakoju, the 16 year old black girl who was shot to death because she was in the wrong place at the wrong time?

How many of you who commented on this story wrote a comment about the 5 year old Sri Lankan girl who was in a shop whilst 3 black boys rushed in and shot indiscriminately and a stray bullet hit her leaving her paralyzed?

How many of you who wrote a comment on this story
wrote a comment about the murder of a young black16-year-old by the name of Yemurai Kanyangarara who was stabbed to death by....surprise,surprise a group of black boys.

The simple answer is None of you!

You are all more concerned about rappers and weaves-ons, than you are about innocent black people being slaughtered by black wannabee UK Jamaican gangstars .Yes , UK born JAMAICAN wannabee gangstars because they are they ones who in the main ( Not people from the islands of Barbados,Dominica, St.Kits, St.Lucia, St.Vincent, Antigua) etc who are responsible for killing innocent black youngsters than white people. However you see no evil , hear no evil or talk no evil because you're more concerned with the culture of celebrity than getting the black human rats off the streets of London.
SHAME ON YOU!!!!

Sat, 2011-07-16 12:46

I asked them, the other day,

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

I asked them, the other day, what's the matter with the Jamaicans?!! I haven't had an answer yet! I don't suppose they know themselves?!!

Sun, 2011-07-24 16:51

Rass, me bro, I had to double

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

Rass, me bro, I had to double check to make sure that I hadn't written that piece and forgotten cos that's virtually everything that I would have said, almost word for word. I comment on most incidents but there're so many of these stories that I don't bother to respond to every single one but, suffice to say, I agree with you 100%. Mind you, in all fiarness I must say that even some of our own people now, unbelievably even a WOMAN, in one case, are getting fed up with all the weave and make up nonsense, as in the Beyonce story but, I agree with you. You echo my words precisely, in every regard! Very well said!

Sun, 2011-07-24 16:47

Don't you know its in bad

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

Don't you know its in bad taste to comment on stories about someone who has died? Many times you cannot even leave a comment about a crime, as the website wont take comments as the case is still in court and you are not allowed to comment on it. If you look into it, you will find there is such a thing as sub judice. In law, sub judice, Latin for "under judgment", means that a particular case or matter is currently under trial or being considered by a judge or court. The term may be used synonymously with "the present case" or "the case at bar" by some lawyers. So you cant go onto stories about many crimes and leave long comments as you dont have the option. Also it is in bad taste to leave remarks unless you know the victim or the family, its called having respect for the deceased.
That does not mean people dont have strong emotions when they hear of someone dying. But to tell us to all go and leave comments about a teenager who was killed is both rude, ignorant, and shows a total lack of understanding of British common law. We can comment at liberty about Beyonce, for we are not breaking any laws by doing so, and our comments are moderated! So please!

Sat, 2011-07-16 23:00

Double Standards

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

What about the killing of Stephen Lawrence. Although unfortunately no one has been convicted, i remember very well the hysteria and comments from the black community and rightly so. If that is the case then we should be able to make comments about all those young black men that have been killed in this country by other young black men. Sorry but you cannot have it both ways.

Wed, 2011-10-19 17:50

"How many of you people who

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

"How many of you people who found the time to comment about" - your quote
I comment on many things, and post on many forums on various real life issues. Im sorry but acting like a total pr*t isnt going to make and difference is it now? And how can you tell who comments on what and when? Are you claiming to be psychic?
If you are it isnt working; stick to your day job!

Sat, 2011-07-16 22:39

It seems that people forget

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

It seems that people forget that beyonce is extremely talented ,instead they always concentrate on her looks.
When an individual has extreme talent,record companies will do anything to sell them to the maximum amount of people.
Even the notorious Big was wearing make up and fly wall street type suits when he was hot,hot,hot.
people should leave bey alone.

Fri, 2011-07-15 22:50

This is Complete and Utter Nonsense

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

This is complete inflammatory nonsense.

Yes there is a legitimate debate to be had about the favour bestowed on lighter skinned black people generally (from within the black community as much as out side of it....) but this article is nonsense.

To say: "Many young black women have unrealistic expectations of looking like the superstar singer" is complete and utter nonsense.

Thats assuming that 'black' looks one way and one way only. Its ridiculous to blame Beyonce for her genes any more than it is to blame Wesley Snipes for his.

To suggest that Beyonce is somehow responsible for black womens' unrealistic expectations is so idiotic.

The truth is that the black press would prefer to talk about Beyonce and demonise her simply because talking about her sells papers/attracts extra interest. This is the height of hypocrisy.

The debate about light skin vs dark skin is one to have within the context of the western world in general - it is not fair to single out one successful person and use her as a scapegoat for all of the ills (and also ill-behaviour!) suffered by black people in general and darker skinned black people in particular.

Lets raise the game eh, The Voice?

Fri, 2011-07-15 16:29

NodWoifHlAddqy

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

Your article perfcetly shows what I needed to know, thanks!

Tue, 2011-08-16 10:45

Beyonce is put forward as the

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

Beyonce is put forward as the "ideal woman/black woman" by the music industry, and in turn by the media.
If she has been lightening her skin, straightening her nose, and colouring her hair blonde, she is "living upto" the expectations the music industry demand.
Clearly if the most successful or one of the most successful black female singers has to do all this to become very successful, despite the fact that she was fairly light in colour to begin with, it sets a depressing president for young black women.
I don't think the Voice are wrong to highlight her. Who do they speak of? They cant speak about Prince, yes he did all the same, but he isnt really making the headlines. There is a historical context, but unless you discuss it in the present people living in the present will not understand the message!

Fri, 2011-07-15 17:47

They Entertainers, Let them Entertain!!

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

Yeah but, Its cosmetic innit. She can do what she wants and as for betraying black folk, why, Coz she wants to sell more records? I'm black and Beyonce aint betraying me. I sell other stuff. Like Cartel said, them folk entertain. They entertainers, like clowns almost. Let them clown about with their looks if they want. Thats up to them.
Teach your kids not to worship what they see on TV and they will be OK. Girls don't run the world either Bey... sorry!

Fri, 2011-07-15 15:50

Its been going on for

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

Its been going on for decades, and it wasnt women who started it either. It was men who kick started this idea of changing themselves. Prince did it first, then Michael Jackson, then a host of other male stars.
The women actually didnt follow for quite awhile.

I totally disaprove of skin bleaching and altering your features.
I understand that they wish to make a lot of money in an industry which is full of ideas of so called "white beauty" and has been at the forefront of upholding white supremacy ever since.
(One only has to look at how white singers like Elvis were made into "kings" in black music genres, to realise why black singers began to bleach in the first place.)
The blame really lies with the racism in the industry.
I cant even say "the public demand it" for I believe the people who run the music industry are racists, and promote their own agenda of white supremacy, and dont really care about what the public think.
It is setting bad role models for young black women, basically telling them black isnt beautiful, and you have to be white or whitish to make any money.
For it to stop the culture of racism which controls the music industry has to stop. Music needs its own "affirmative action". Laws need to be passed to stop the discrimination in the music industry which would be unheard of in many other walks of life. Where a less talented white artist is given much more promotion and investment than a more talented black artist almost as a matter of course.
Where white less talented singers are signed in preference to black singers, or given chances on covertly racist shows such as the various "idol" shows on television.
The music industry should hold its head in shame. It is run by corporations and individuals who do not follow the laws of integration as do other bodies and organisations. There is no attempt made to pull the music industry into the 21st century. The same rules which saw Elvis Presley crowned "king" and Chuck Berry thrown into prison to grease his path to fame, and the Beatles promoted over many talented black acts, is alive and well today. In the music industry we are still stuck in a time wharp, around the year 1953.

Fri, 2011-07-15 16:37

Some interesting points, but

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

Some interesting points, but this piece was all over the place. Firstly, Bey is not the first black woman to straighten her hair (or her nose) or go blonde. That's been going on for YEARS.

Secondly, black women are more affluent and visible - why shouldn't we spend our money getting things done and fixed, like white women feel entitled to?

Thirdly, Beyonce no more represents me than 'the average Sheniqua' does.

Fourth, we KNOW these people represent some arbitrary ideal of perfection. Humans will always chase after what they cannot have - this is why you see so many women wearing ill-advised wigs and weaves.

Fifth, I'd agree that we need to see more brown and dark women held up as beauty icons. We know we're beautiful in all colours, so we need to support those who look like us. We can't all look like Beyonce or Cassie; the Kellys and the Jennifers and the Alek Weks represent us too.

Dark, brown, fair, natural and weavalicious - this is what black women are today, so yes. Let's widen the beauty standards a bit.

Fri, 2011-07-15 11:44

why 'white'. stars like beyonce are betraying black women.

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

Its each to their own I suppose if Nicki. M wants to rock her hair they she does and beyonce wants to go blond then let them, but I aint seen either one rock a natural look yet! As for having surgery to alter the look to a more european identity then, that's an issue of insecurity they need to deal with...sooner rather than later because I for one am up in all three of my sisters faces letting them know that their dark skin is blessed and beautiful, they don't need to look like any of those mentioned stars to get anywhere... with god they can go as far as they please!..forshame, forshame!

Fri, 2011-07-15 11:42

Bull

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

Why should Beyonce's idea of beauty be a betrayal of black women? If it is, any idea of "beauty" as prescribed by fashion trends and the collective need for many to dance to the tune of consumerism, is a betrayal too. Why is it a betrayal of black women? It is if all you do is obsess about race. Millions of people go through each day unaware of race, as defined by the peurile obsessive who sees nothing but colour as yardstick for defining identity- like this journalist. Judge people on the basis of much more important criteria. Beyonce's betrayal is to herself you halfwit!

Fri, 2011-07-15 11:25

It is the return of the

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

It is the return of the 'paperbag' and 'pencil test' as far black women in the popular music worldis concerned. The mulatto reigns supreme.
Ironically it was the whitepress which made black models such as Naomi Simms acceptable and in the worl of cllassical music, the abilities if the women rsther than hercomplexion count. Among the current superstars are the opera singers Jessye Norman, Denyce Graves, Barbara Hendrix et al.

Fri, 2011-07-15 10:47

why 'white' stars like Beyonce

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous

Ironically in opera an art form favoured by upper ckasswhites, the major female superstar are black, Jessye Norman, Grace Bumbry, Deneyce Graves, Barbara Hendricks et al

Fri, 2011-07-15 10:38