Anyone ‘should be allowed to identify as black, regardless of their skin colour’ says university union

Universities and Colleges Union have insisted that people should be able to choose their own gender and race

CONTROVERSY: Rachel Dolezal (Photo credit: The Real / YouTube)

A UNIVERSITY union has claimed anyone should be allowed to identify as black regardless of their skin colour or background.

The stance was revealed in a report from The Universities and Colleges Union, centered around the ongoing debate about whether men should be able to self-identify as women, after they faced criticism over their labelling of transgender people.

The body, which represents 120,000 academics, said in their statement that they agree with self identification of gender, but also race.

The union said: “Our rules commit us to ending all forms of discrimination, bigotry and stereotyping. UCU has a long history of enabling members to self-identify whether that is being black, disabled, LGBT+ or women.”

They added: ‘UCU also supports a social, rather than medical, model of gender recognition that will help challenge repressive gender stereotypes in the workplace and in society.’

Many criticised the union’s position on race, including union member and Sussex University philosophy professor Kathleen Stock, who said the union’s position on race was “nonsensical, anti-intellectual propaganda.”

Stock added: “It’s fairly simple: being a woman, being black, and being disabled are each causal factors in distinctive patterns of mistreatment & discrimination. Does @ucu think academics should be allowed to use distinctive names & non-subjective categories for those causal factors, or not?”

Another commentator said the statement was “racist and stupid.”

CONTROVERSY

In the US, Rachel Dolezal self-identified as a black woman but was exposed as a white woman during a TV interview, sparking a worldwide debate.
She quit her post as an official at the National Association for the Advancement of coloured People in 2015, after her parents confirmed she was not black.

In the UK, white theatre director Anthony Lennon faced criticism for identifying as an “African born again” and securing public funding intended to help develop the careers of those from underrepresented communities.

Comments Form

31 Comments

  1. | Everyman

    If everything can be X, nothing is X.

    Reply

  2. | anthony

    black is the first color on the color chart all people come from black people!

    Reply

    • | timcro@virginmedia.com

      IDK, IMO, IJS

      Reply

  3. | Howard Johnson

    B.S. What is the University really trying to say? Anybody that is White can claim to be Black ,if they want to? 🤔

    Reply

  4. | Betty

    I disagree

    Reply

  5. | Phyllis Grayson

    Rachel Dolezal should have been left alone she did not take anything that I can see from anyone, she sought to help and I hope she is doing well despite the media hype. Grace and Peace ✌🏾

    Reply

    • | Jaz

      She could have help a lot more ppl as her authentic self

      Reply

      • | Ryan

        Who are YOU to determine what her Authentic self is. Sorry if you can identify as a coffee table… which biology says your not then someone can identify as what ever race they want and saying just black well that’s racist.

        Reply

    • | Ptah Williamson

      Yeah many Whites have for years identified themselves as the offspring of Ancient Egyptians SMH

      Reply

  6. | Racquel Karriem

    As he should have if he wanted to collect those funds and let people know that he was of another race but still wanted to reach out in that manner people would still help. So the fact that he tried to create some type of identity just to be able to help people is not genuine help. It makes him look guilty of having other real interest.

    Reply

  7. | Chef

    I thought the human race consists of man and mankind.The color code system still exists and the university scholars should teach the students its status not skin color

    Reply

  8. | Earlie Clendion

    Then, if you want to identify as Black, also accept the discrimination in housing, accept the killings and beatings from cops, accept having the cops called on you for simply living, accept the discrimination in education, workplace and let’s not forget the discrimination of you wanting to wear your natural hair. Accept being followed in stores or not being able to rent an apartment…the list goes on. You want to identify as Black, come now into our world and let the games began. Only for us it is not a game. This is our LIFE you privileged, souless jerks!!!

    Reply

    • | kizzie

      mic drop

      Reply

  9. | Jason

    In the reverse anybody should be able to identify as a white male and gain the priveleges

    Reply

  10. | John

    The UCU is off it’s rocker. A white person can’t claim to be black anymore than a black persons can claim to be white. Gender identity is a completely different matter.

    Reply

  11. | Dorton

    If people maintain that everyone descended from Africa, then essentially everyone is of African descent.

    Reply

    • | King P

      All Africans are not black.

      Reply

  12. | LisetteM

    Ok, since anyone “should be allowed to identify as black, regardless of their skin colour’ Can white males identify as “black women”????

    Reply

  13. | Orlando

    Welll i guess a dog is a cat now
    This world has become so ignorant.

    Reply

  14. | Regina Reese

    Just like the transgender debacle, you can claim to be a woman, but if you don’t have a vagina, you will NEVER be a woman. Like Rachel Dolezal, she may feel like she’s a black woman but short of having black parents, or even half black parents, she could not claim to be black. No one white has ever had the experience of being discriminated against because of skin color. In fact, this entire issue of claiming blackness is only designed to falsify information on paper in order to achieve benefits designed to equal the racist playing field. Give it a rest.

    Reply

  15. | Cyrus

    How about accepting people as they are and practice real equality and equity. This will not solve the problem it will only make it worse because of its stupidity.

    Reply

  16. | Clifton

    Race, creed, color, sex and even disability are and can be identified by natural characteristic! Blood, DNA and scientific con conclusions should remaining factors! Just as a Birth certificate, some documentation can be altered by way of AMENDMENT…but you are who you born as! IJS!👀😁☻👨‍🦰👨‍🦳💯

    Reply

  17. | John

    I love this woman. She’s more black than the 95% of black women I know

    Reply

  18. | Laura

    Just be a decent human being

    Reply

  19. | PD

    No…. white people have NOT been discriminated against because of their skin color… but Yes I’m white and I most certainly have been discriminated against because I had a black husband and 3 mixed children…. everybody’s stories are different and I just wanted to put this out there

    Reply

  20. | Barbara

    The law says if you have one eighth black blood in you you are black. Are they going to change that?

    Reply

  21. | Alice

    How?

    Reply

  22. | Marie

    Damn. That is the craziest thing I ever heard. Can I identify as Asian? Because my eyes are almond shaped. Or 30 because Im spunky? Gtfoh! It is ridiculous. I am African American woman. I identify with who and what I am! Stop hating yourself! I love me!

    Reply

  23. | Gary Thompson

    With the ongoing debate amongst American presidential candidates about reparations, all of which come out tax payers pockets, it appears that anyone and everyone can get paid.

    Absolutely stupid on more levels than I can count.

    Reply

  24. | Kab

    That’s offensive and belittling to Black people.

    Reply

  25. | Ananda Sattwa

    There are no legitimate reasons or a white person to be designated for black.it is not okay. ridiculous. Only if they could share our abuse and unfair circumstances.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*
*

Support The Voice

The Voice Newspaper is committed to celebrating black excellence, campaigning for positive change and informing the black community on important issues. Your financial contributions are essential to protect the future of the publication as we strive to help raise the profile of the black communities across the UK. Any size donation is welcome and we thank you for your continued support.

Support Sign-up

Related