Jesus saves… do you?

Black churches are keeping cash in the community and helping businesses thrive.

CONTROVERSIAL: Black churches have been criticised for embracing ‘prosperity gospel’ (Pic: Barbara Davidson/Getty Images)

THE BLACK church has long played an important role in black communities. 

Despite the hardships that the Windrush Generation encountered as they adjusted to life in Britain, many found a sense of community and comfort in the church. 

But the role of the black church in helping create economic mobility and generational wealth has largely been overlooked. 

Church members would pool their resources to form pardner schemes or credit unions – a cooperative that acts like a banking service.

The success of these organisations meant that congregants bypassed the discrimination of mainstream banks while buying property or being able to afford to send for their children in the Caribbean, or launch a business.

SUPPORT: Mark McIver has received backing from the Pentecostal Credit Union

The global protests that followed the death of George Floyd in May 2020 sparked an intense national debate, both here and in the UK, about the links between economic and racial inequality.

Mirroring what was happening in the US, individuals and community groups in the UK backed up their words with action by moving their money away from banks and into organisations such as the Pentecostal Credit Union (PCU) – the UK’s largest  black-led credit union – as part of a powerful display of economic solidarity.

“We certainly experienced a spike of new customers in the aftermath of George Floyd’s murder” says PCU’s CEO Shane Bowes.

“This has coincided with recent reports over the last year or so that loan applications from black small businesses are more likely to be turned down to mainstream banks than businesses run by people of other ethnicities.  

“These negative outcomes, in addition to the issues that came out of the George Floyd protests, have increased the number of people taking their money out of banks or coming to us as their first port of call.”

ENTERPRISE: Jemma Regis successfully launched her cake business

The trend also reflected a growing debate about how best the black community could achieve generational wealth. 

According to a December 2020 report by think tank Resolution Foundation people of African Caribbean heritage typically hold the lowest wealth (a median figure of £24,000 family wealth per adult), which amounts to less than one eighth of the typical wealth held by a person of White British ethnicity (£197,000 family wealth per adult). 

The goal of improving the bleak outlook painted by these statistics recently led the PCU to launch a new drive aimed at Millennials.

GiftBox! is a suite of financial services aimed at helping young people make long-term choices about their personal finances that will ultimately help them achieve goals such as getting out of debt, creating wealth, or becoming entrepreneurs 

As well as offering competitive loans and high-interest savings accounts to members, who do not have to be Pentecostal churchgoers, GiftBox! will run Money Masterclasses aimed at improving members’ financial literacy and entrepreneurial skills. 

Although the PCU’s story is unique it will sound familiar to many black Britons.

It was founded in 1980 by Rev Carmel Jones, a minister in the Church of God in Christ. He wanted to help black people, in particular members of the Windrush Generation, to bypass discrimination they faced from mainstream financial institutions when trying to obtain funding for projects such as launching businesses or building new churches.

The fact that the credit union had members who knew each other and felt morally obliged to repay loans because of this helped the organisation to grow quickly. 

The credit union model also allowed members to save and lend money in a way that kept it circulating within the community, rather than enriching a few wealthy shareholders at the expense of others.

OUTCOMES: Shane Bowes says black small businesses are more likely to be turned down by banks. 

Today the PCU has assets of £13 million and is part of a growing sector.

According to Bank of England’s data released early last year 1.93 million people in the UK are now members of a credit union, an increase of more than 22,000 compared to the same period in 2021. 

Bowes says supporting aspiring business owners is vital to the long-term economic welfare of the community. 

“Anywhere you go in the world you’ll see a community like a Little China or a Little India for example,” he says. 

“And within those communities you’ll see a bedrock of entrepreneurship. You’ll see shops, you’ll see businesses, you’ll see a hotbed of activity. That community is being driven and financed by its entrepreneurial spirit. So we believe that in order to drive forward the economic empowerment of our community, entrepreneurship is really important.”

Mark McIver, owner of barbershop business Slider Cuts, says the backing he received from PCU was crucial to helping his business get off the ground. 

“When I started my business I was struggling to find funding and get loans from places because they felt I had maxed out on my credit” he recalls. 

“PCU looked at me, looked at my situation. They had a conversation with me instead of what the mainstream banks did when I approached them, which was to rely on a computer to make a decision and then ultimately say no.”

Recent years have seen criticisms levelled at black churches both here and in the US over a growing embrace of what has been called ‘prosperity gospel’.

Unlike the focus on social justice and tackling discrimination that marked black church leadership in the 1950s and 60s, prosperity gospel followers believe God wills those who are “born again” to be materially wealthy and free of disease. 

Its popularity over the last two decades has seen the emergence of celebrity ministers who create wealthy megachurches and preach theology critics say supports a vision of capitalism that has been devastating to black communities. 

The view that organisations like PCU – and black churches in the UK –  reflect this theology is one that author and entrepreneur Jemma Regis rejects. 

Regis is the founder of Jemz Cake Box as well as two other businesses and, like McIver,  worked with the credit union to successfully launch her companies. 

“When my mum died in 1987, they were instrumental in my dad just holding on to the property our family had” she recalls. “When he couldn’t get support from anywhere else, they were there.

“They’re not driving around in massive jeeps or living in six-bedroom houses. They are very much community focused. They want to support the community and they have the heart to help people who really can’t get that support from elsewhere.”

Comments Form

2 Comments

  1. | Chaka Artwell

    In the 1970s and 80s, the independent; sovereign, property-owning, Caribbean-led Churches, offered the best prospect in terms of leadership: vision and upward mobility for Her Majesty’s Caribbean-heritage Subjects.

    Youth Convention in Leicester, organised by the New Testament Church of God, were an impressive: massive and joyous event, filled with England’s Caribbean-heritage youth: steeped in the knowledge of the Hebrew Scriptures; determined to shine in English society, whilst being an example of the Semitic Hebrew Messiah, and his crucifixion example.

    By the 1980s, the decline of the Caribbean-led Churches was swift; and stemmed from three sources.
    1: The Caribbean leader wanted to hold onto their “old time religion,” and they refused to properly engage themselves, or help their Caribbean youth to cope with the reality of being of Caribbean-heritage in a society that marginalised Caribbean-heritage youth.

    2: When the riots started, the Church had nothing to say; nothing to offer, and did not intercede in any meaningful way with the institutional discrimination that kept Caribbean-heritage Subjects on the margins of English society.

    Lastly, the hubris from the Caribbean Pastors; Ministers and Exalters was such that I cannot recall a single sermon, even a reference to Dr Martin Luther King: Marcus Garvey, Malcolm X, their life, vision, message, and achievement.

    In the 1980s, when discrimination against Caribbean-heritage youth was off the scale in England’s public and corporate institutions, knowledge about us as Caribbean-heritage English born youth, did not come from the Caribbean-led Churches.

    Indeed, we learnt more about ourselves as African-heritage youth from listening closely to Bob Marley’s lyrically important musical compositions.

    England’s Caribbean-heritage youth required cultural and historical knowledge to counter English societies’ rejection.

    However, the Caribbean Church refused to see us as a cultural people, desperately trying to re-orientate ourselves after enduring two hundred years of savage and brutal slavery: largely to the Anglican Church, that owned the greatest numbers of Caribbean as slaves in the English Caribbean.

    In short, England Caribbean youth of the 1980s desperately required a MOSES; but the Caribbean-led Churches were not offering a MOSES, they were offering platitudes; prayer, and a form of religion that could not satisfy the soul of England’s Caribbean YOUTH.

    I notice today, that the mega churches are led by Africans.

    Having attended many, the formula of excessive singing; clapping and physical exuberance, does not satisfy the soul of African-heritage YOUTH.
    The African-led Churches enjoy numerical success; but the laity is shockingly transient; and display an infantile knowledge of the Christian creed; to which they have pledge alliance.

    I would welcome the African-led; and Caribbean-led Churches, offering visionary theological: political, historical, economic, and cultural leadership to His Majesty’s African-heritage Subjects.

    Alas, there is no sign that African-heritage Pastors would welcome this role, and leadership responsibility for His Majesty’s African-heritage Christian Subjects.

    Reply

  2. | Yvonne Christie

    Not sure who wrote that critique of churches but i agree wholeheartedly that most Black led churches have not adequately served their black communities needs. Spiritually or socially.
    Yes they are good at visiting the sick but there is much they could have done over the years to support and uplift. They collect soooo much money from donations yet i dont see it going back. I see pastors, their wives and children looking wealthy and esteemed but dont see it shared amongst ‘the flock’. And besides we mostly now understand western religious concepts have been used to keep black people down and its as though black church leaders dont address and include that in their sermon except to say its the weakness of man. Of which they are a part of such weaknesses too. Additionally they dont challenge the powers that be about the continued mistreatment of black youngers in particular in the UK…i question ‘why not’ and therefore conclude that black church leaders themselves have internalised racism and they too think our people deserve the rubbish dished out. To read this pentecostal church is different is a surprise and a possible beacon for others to follow. But im still sceptical because some of the pastors are still manipulative and sexual deviants and throw money into that mix and i can see negative operations developing. But just call me honest, blunt and a realist!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*
*

Support The Voice

The Voice Newspaper is committed to celebrating black excellence, campaigning for positive change and informing the black community on important issues. Your financial contributions are essential to protect the future of the publication as we strive to help raise the profile of the black communities across the UK. Any size donation is welcome and we thank you for your continued support.

Support Sign-up